The Next Chapter of Emerging Markets

As part of Nasdaq’s Index Options team, I focus on content. This includes information conveyed through a variety of mediums, but in my opinion, the best content is narrative-based. I believe humans use and connect with stories on a very basic level. It’s something that sets us apart from other forms of life. It’s part of what catapulted homo sapiens to the top of the food chain.

So, what’s the next chapter for emerging markets?

Emerging Markets

In truth, nobody knows, but there’s certainly opportunity and risk. Let’s understand what constitutes an “emerging market” (EM) and how these developing areas have performed historically through the lens of a few indexes. With some sense of where we came from, the jump to where we might go is far less foreboding.

An “emerging market” according to the International Monetary Fund (IMF), is characterized by “their high degree of volatility… with transitions occurring in economic, political, social and demographic dimensions.” These countries often exhibit some, but not all the traits associated with a developed economy.

In the visual above, the orange areas of the map illustrate the sizeable portion of the world considered “emerging” from an economic standpoint. The amber color indicates a “frontier” market which is less liquid and typically risker than an emerging nation.

EMs offer the potential for high return on investment because they can experience elevated growth rates relative to developed economies. EMs typically focus on export markets (commodities). As a result, they typically experience more cyclical growth as opposed to secular. They also tend to have lower per-capita incomes in part because of their dependence on international trade.

The most well-known EM economies include Brazil, Russia, India and China (BRICs). Following the global financial crisis (2007 – 2009), these countries helped stimulate growth as they expanded domestically and internationally.

Performance

There’s not a correct way to measure the performance of EMs. For example, what countries do you include? Which securities are weighted most heavily? When does a nation graduate to “developed” status?

There are a variety of indexes designed to track EM performance. For example, the NASDAQ Emerging Markets Index (NQEM) is a float adjusted market cap weighted index that includes securities in countries designated as EMs.

Another index dates back further and will be used to compare relative performance. Specifically, how and when EMs have under or outperformed compared to developed markets.

LONGTERMTRENDS & NASDAQ

As the chart illustrates, there have been long periods of meaningful outperformance on the part of EMs ((1989 – 1994, 2002 – 2008, and 2009 – 2010). There have also been extended stretches where EMs dramatically underperformed compared to developed markets (DM).

Since 2010, the trend relative to DMs has been lower. There’s no single point of attribution. However, the post-2010 period has been defined by historically low interest rates globally. The relative cost of money has significant knock-on effects, including in the currency markets.

The U.S. Dollar (USD) has been a global reserve currency in the post-WWII era. In short, that means that most of the international trade is denominated in USD. When the U.S. Dollar is strong relative to foreign currencies, EMs tend to underperform.

TRADING ECONOMICS & NASDAQ

Countries & Constituents

The largest constituent holdings for the MSCI Emerging Markets Index are Taiwan Semiconductor, Tencent Holdings, Samsung and Alibaba. They make up slightly more than 17% of the overall index.

The leading firms represent Taiwan, China (Tencent and Alibaba) as well as South Korea. Asian-domiciled firms constitute about 77% of the index. Latin America makes up about 9%. Middle Eastern companies account for 7.2%. Africa follows at 3.18% with a small European contingent.

From a price return standpoint, the Emerging Market Index (EEM) is essentially unchanged over the past decade. By comparison, the Nasdaq 100® Index (NDX) has gained more than 400%. The S&P 500 Index (SPX) is up over 160% over the same time frame. EM investors have mostly been left behind and are waiting for the tide to turn.

FIDELITY AND NASDAQ

The Mighty USD

During the most recent Federal Reserve rate hike cycle, the U.S. Dollar rallied to the highest levels in 20 years. The USD peaked in September of last year and has been slowly grinding lower for the past three quarters. Despite the decline, the dollar remains strong on a longer-term basis.

The proverbial tide may turn for EM economies if/when the dollar weakens considerably. The U.S. remains a global superpower – economically, militarily and politically. Thus far concerns over the current debt-to-GDP ratio have not rattled many macro investors.

Will the electric vehicle/clean energy markets catalyze growth in EM economies where the requisite commodities can be mined?

Will the U.S. economy fall into recession and move the Federal Reserve to start reducing rates?

Could there be a geopolitical event that alters nearly 80 years of U.S. hegemony?

Going Forward

The Chinese economy has an outsized influence on the performance of most EM Indexes and the tradeable products designed to track them.

WORLD BANK & NASDAQ

If you believe the 2023 projections for Chinese GDP growth, then perhaps EM investments are approaching an inflection point. The Chinese economy has struggled to maintain a forward trajectory in the “post-pandemic” environment.

Like any investment, there are opportunities and risks. Keep in mind there are option-based strategies that afford market participants the ability to define their exposure over specific time frames. 

—

Originally Posted July 24, 2023 – The Next Chapter of Emerging Markets

The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Nasdaq, Inc.